SOURCES — "POV: You're About To Experience Artificial Selection" =============================================================== THE HOOK — NATURAL VS ARTIFICIAL SELECTION ------------------------------------------ • Artificial selection = humans, not nature, deciding who gets to have offspring. Darwin opens On the Origin of Species with it: - Darwin, C. (1859). "On the Origin of Species." John Murray, ch. 1 "Variation under Domestication". 1. SPARTA — THE BABY INSPECTION ------------------------------- • The story of elders inspecting newborns and throwing weak ones into a chasm (the Apothetae) at the foot of Mount Taygetus comes from one writer, Plutarch, who lived around 100 AD, centuries after classical Sparta: - Plutarch, "Life of Lycurgus" 16. (Perrin translation, Loeb 1914) https://lexundria.com/plut_lyc/16/prr • The pit itself (Keadas / Kaiadas): bones of adolescents and adults aged about 18-35, no newborns: - Theodoros Pitsios (University of Athens Medical School), reported in "Spartans did not throw deformed babies away: researchers," via History News Network. https://www.historynewsnetwork.org/article/45504 • The opening of "300" (2006, dir. Zack Snyder, Warner Bros.) stages Plutarch's version. Clips shown for commentary. • The family scene (three days old, the oldest elder squinting) is dramatised. 2. THE POTSDAM GIANTS --------------------- • King Frederick William I of Prussia's regiment of tall soldiers (the "Lange Kerls"); men bought, tricked and kidnapped from across Europe, others sent as gifts by foreign rulers; tall soldiers married off to tall women; minimum height six Prussian feet, about 1.88 m: - "Potsdam Giants," Wikipedia (and the sources it cites). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potsdam_Giants • No study shows the regiment changed the average height of Prussia. "No evidence it did," not "proven it didn't." • The cabbages, the sack and the alley are dramatised. 3. THE FERTILITY DOCTOR — DONALD CLINE (AND BERTOLD WIESNER) ------------------------------------------------------------ • Dr. Donald Cline, Indianapolis, 1974-1987: told patients they were getting sperm from anonymous medical residents or students, used his own. DNA tests have confirmed 94 of his children (as of May 2022): - "Donald Cline," Wikipedia (and the court and news reporting it cites). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Cline - "Our Father" (2022), documentary, Netflix. • No prison: Indiana had no law against it. He pleaded guilty in 2017 to two counts of obstruction of justice (lying to investigators) and got a suspended sentence. • Indiana made fertility fraud a crime in 2019 (Senate Enrolled Act 174): - Pew Stateline (2019-07-03). "Fighting Fertility Fraud: New State Laws Go After Misuse of Sperm." https://stateline.org/2019/07/03/fighting-fertility-fraud-new-state-laws-go-after-misuse-of-sperm/ • Bertold Wiesner and his wife Mary Barton's London clinic (1940s-60s): DNA tests in 2007 on 18 people conceived there found 12 were his. "Up to 600" is an extrapolation by two of those children (David Gollancz and Barry Stevens), not a count: - "Mary Barton (obstetrician)," Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Barton_(obstetrician) - Reported by The Sunday Times, 2012; see also PROGRESS Educational Trust, "Scientist allegedly fathered 600 children at own sperm clinic." https://www.progress.org.uk/scientist-allegedly-fathered-600-children-at-own-sperm-clinic/ • The patient, her husband, the baby boy and his DNA test "for fun" are dramatised. Half-siblings who went to the same schools: told by Cline's donor children in "Our Father". 4. THE PLANTATION — ROQUE JOSÉ FLORÊNCIO ("PATA SECA") ----------------------------------------------------- • Born around 1827 in Sorocaba; acquired by Francisco da Cunha Bueno, owner of Fazenda Santa Eudóxia near São Carlos, São Paulo; designated a "breeding slave" because of his height; did not live in the slave quarters or work the fields; looked after the animals and rode for the mail; after abolition (1888) he received land, married Palmira and had nine children with her; died 1958: - "Roque José Florêncio," Portuguese Wikipedia (and the sources it cites: Revista Galileu, Aventuras na História, Agência Pública, Brasil de Fato). https://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roque_Jos%C3%A9_Flor%C3%AAncio • "About 200 children" is his descendants' claim; the records are thin and nobody can count them: - Audi, A. (2025-01-23). "Mulheres eram forçadas a engravidar em fazendas de reprodução de escravizados." Agência Pública (also published by Brasil de Fato). https://apublica.org/2025/01/mulheres-eram-forcadas-a-engravidar-em-fazendas-de-reproducao-de-escravizados/ • Farms for breeding enslaved people did exist in Brazil (historian Laurentino Gomes names farms in Remígio, Paraíba and Mangaratiba, Rio de Janeiro): same Agência Pública article. • The only known photo of him (1940s, family archive), public domain: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:%C3%9Anica_foto_conhecida_de_Roque_Jos%C3%A9_Flor%C3%AAncio,_o_Pata_Seca,_supercentenario_e_ex_escravizado_Brasileiro.jpg • The AI-generated "Pata Seca" pictures in the video are shown as examples of images that could NOT be confirmed. None of them is him. • NOTE: he was born in Sorocaba; the slave-market scene set there is dramatised. 5. THE PERFECT SPERM DONOR — TP53 --------------------------------- • One donor to the European Sperm Bank (Denmark), used for about 17 years: at least 197 children across 14 countries; a new TP53 mutation (Li-Fraumeni syndrome, high cancer risk) in up to about 20% of his sperm but not in the rest of his body, so standard screening missed it; some of the children have died of cancer. Not all 197 children carry it: - European Broadcasting Union Investigative Journalism Network (December 2025), with 14 public broadcasters including the BBC. - CNN (2025-12-10). "At least 197 children were fathered by sperm donor with cancer-causing gene, some have already died." https://abc17news.com/cnn-health/2025/12/10/at-least-197-children-were-fathered-by-sperm-donor-with-cancer-causing-gene-some-have-already-died/ • The 2012 couch, the wine and the app are dramatised. 6. SCREENING BEFORE BIRTH — DOWN SYNDROME ----------------------------------------- • Iceland: close to 100% of pregnancies with a prenatal Down syndrome diagnosis are terminated; Denmark 98% (2015). These are rates among DIAGNOSED pregnancies; screening is optional (taken by about 80-85% of women in Iceland): - CBS News, "CBSN: On Assignment" (August 2017). "'What kind of society do you want to live in?': Inside the country where Down syndrome is disappearing." https://www.cbsnews.com/news/down-syndrome-iceland/ 7. GATTACA ---------- • The story in this door is the plot of "Gattaca" (1997, written and directed by Andrew Niccol, Columbia Pictures): the "in-valid" Vincent, the borrowed identity of Jerome, the blood and urine bags, the doctor who lets him fly. Poster shown for commentary. 8. PICKING EMBRYOS TODAY — NUCLEUS ---------------------------------- • What the company itself claims, choosing from 5 embryos: "+10.8 IQ points" and "+3.1 inches taller" (best vs worst embryo, a modelled expectation, not a measured result): - Nucleus Genomics, embryo page (checked 2026-10-26). https://mynucleus.com/embryo - Nucleus Genomics, traits whitepaper ("Revisiting the limited utility of embryo screening"). https://mynucleus.com/labs/traits-whitepaper • Independent estimate of the gain from picking the top-scoring embryo: about 2.5 IQ points and 2.5 cm on average, with wide error: - Karavani, E. et al. (2019). "Screening Human Embryos for Polygenic Traits Has Limited Utility." Cell 179(6):1424-1435. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2019.10.033 • The video is not an ad and was not paid for; the screenshots are shown for commentary. • "The full package starts at 30 bands": the full package is Nucleus IVF+ (one IVF cycle with medications, carrier screening of both parents, embryo screening of up to 20 embryos, counseling). CBS News reported it at $30,000 in 2025; Nucleus's own page now lists it from $9,999/month for four months, depending on location (checked 2026-10-26). Screening alone, for people already doing IVF elsewhere (Nucleus Embryo), is $9,999. - CBS News (2025). "Nucleus Genomics CEO explains how 'genetic optimization' tools help parents select traits they desire in babies." https://www.cbsnews.com/news/nucleus-genomics-ceo-genetic-optimization-tools-parents-select-traits-babies/ - Nucleus IVF+ page. https://mynucleus.com/ivf 9. MY DAUGHTER — "SEVERAL YEARS OF SCHOOL" ----------------------------------------- • One extra year of schooling raises IQ scores by about 1-5 points, so ~10 points is in the range of several years of school: - Ritchie, S.J. & Tucker-Drob, E.M. (2018). "How Much Does Education Improve Intelligence? A Meta-Analysis." Psychological Science 29(8):1358-1369. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797618774253 • The "pre-gene-edited baby", the special class and the filled position are the prof's own worry, not a prediction from a study.